• Home
  • News
    • People moves
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • Caribbean
    • Domicile
    • Europe
    • Latin America
    • North America
    • Middle East
    • US
    • US
    • UK
  • Products
    • Funds
    • Pensions
    • Platforms
    • Insurance
    • Investments
    • Private Banking
    • Citizenship
    • Taxation
  • Fintech
  • Regulation
  • ESG
  • Expats
  • In Depth
  • Special Reports
  • Directory
  • Video
  • Advertise with us
  • Directory
  • Events
  • European Fund Selector
  • Newsletters
  • Follow us
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Newsletters
  • Advertise with us
  • Directory
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
      event logo
      International Investment Nordic Forum 2021

      International Investment is delighted to announce the 2021 International Investment Nordic Forum which will take place on Tuesday March 9, at 9am (GMT). This curated virtual event will be broadcast live and will feature a series of fund manager interviews and presentations, as well as interviews with some of the Nordic regions top fund selectors.

      • Date: 09 Mar 2021
      • ONLINE, ONLINE
      event logo
      Sustainable Investment Festival 2021

      The Sustainable Investment Festival will run online from 22-25 June and will include thought-provoking presentations from renowned keynote speakers, innovative breakout events and sessions specifically tailored to meet the information needs of fund selectors, financial advisers, pension consultants, trustees and scheme managers.

      • Date: 22 Jun 2021
      • Online, Online
      View all events
  • European Fund Selector
International Investment
International Investment

Sponsored by

Sharing Alpha
  • Home
  • News
  • Products
  • Fintech
  • Regulation
  • ESG
  • Expats
  • In Depth
  • Special Reports
  • Video
  • Thematic

Investors must beware of pitfalls posed by ESG ratings

Investors must beware of pitfalls posed by ESG ratings
  • Jeroen Bos
  • 30 January 2020
  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  

The use of environmental, social and governance (ESG) ratings has increased sharply in recent years and entered the mainstream investment arena. Such scores and ratings now constitute an important element of security, fund and mandate selection, which has led to strong growth in the number of ESG rating and data providers. However, ESG ratings present several challenges that asset owners and managers should be aware of when assessing the sustainability of securities, funds and mandates.

NN Investment Partners (NN IP) recognises that ESG scores have come a long way, with quality gradually evolving towards more material and behaviour-based scores and away from the more traditional policy-based scores. Still, investors should remain cautious when using external ESG ratings. "Pitfalls remain, sometimes resulting in counter-intuitive outcomes. However, these pitfalls can be overcome if they are addressed in the right way.

Related articles

  • NN IP & Yale partner in academic research stream on sustainable investing
  • NN IP and Irish Life IM join hands for sustainable strategies
  • NN IP bolsters ESG investment decision process
  • As ESG data sources grow, so do the number of pitfalls - RAM AI


NN IP has identified five common pitfalls investors face when using external ESG rating agencies:  

Size biases can favour larger firms
ESG ratings often display a size bias that gives larger firms better ESG scores on average. This does not necessarily mean that larger companies take better care of the environment or society. More often it is the result of larger companies having more resources to develop and report on their ESG policies and activities.

Sector neutrality can lead to counter-intuitive results
Most ESG scoring methodologies include  a type of sector neutrality. This means that every sector includes the full range of ESG scores. Even in sectors with serious sustainability issues  - such as oil  and gas -  some companies will score highly on ESG metrics. This could lead to a clear conflict with sustainability. Companies active in sectors that are arguably inherently unsustainable, such as tobacco and traditional energy, can still obtain high, above-market-average ESG scores driven by their policies

Correlation is low between ESG rating agencies
The correlation between ESG scores from different data providers is often limited. Research from CSRHub shows that the correlation between ESG scores from different rating agencies can be as low as 0.3, indicating a clear lack of consistency. A recent study from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) also highlighted this discrepancy. This illustrates the subjective nature of ESG scores, which is partly due to the different methodologies applied. The insights and arguments underlying scores can still be valuable, but it is also possible for a single security to have a wide range of ratings

Ratings become stale over time
ESG scores from the traditional rating agencies can become stale. A company's ESG score today is often comparable to its score from three years ago. This can be partly the result of infrequent review cycles and the fact that specific ESG data points do not tend to change much. Yet, there is a risk that changes in underlying ESG trends might take some time to show up in ESG ratings. Thus, new ESG rating agencies are emerging that, by using new technologies, focus more on timely, news flow-driven ESG data, leading to more frequent updates.

Reporting standards are still mostly absent
Collecting high-quality, comprehensive data remains a challenge. A key reason for this is that companies are not required to report on most types of ESG data. Although companies may well volunteer ESG information, this often lacks consistency because regulators do not stipulate standards to the same degree that they demand in financial data, for example.

Jeroen Bos added: "ESG ratings are opinions, not facts, so it is crucial to understand the viewpoints behind them. ESG scores might produce a diversity of outcomes with low correlations but combining different ESG sources with in-house analysis only enriches insights and improves the decision-making process."

NN IP has identified further opportunities for investors to avoid these pitfalls. By focusing on material ESG aspects - i.e., aspects with an impact on a company's long-term ability to generate cash flow and hence its long-term share price - investors can ensure good alignment between ESG integration and improving risk-adjusted returns. As research shows that companies with improving ESG credentials demonstrate better risk-adjusted returns, it is also important to focus on a company's behaviour and momentum towards improvement, rather than its stated policies. Moreover, asset managers and owners can significantly aid improvement in ESG data by engaging with corporates. Finally, the use of new technologies such as natural language processing and machine learning could further improve ESG insights by improving the completeness, timeliness and quality of data sets.

Jeroen Bos is head of Specialised Equity & Responsible Investing, NN Investment Partners

  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
  • Topics
  • Thematic

More on Thematic

BlackRock launches ultrashort bond ESG ETFs range

  • Passive
  • 19 March 2020
Nikko AM releases 2019 sustainability report

  • Thematic
  • 18 March 2020
World Water Day beckons for ESG investors - KBIGI

  • Thematic
  • 17 March 2020
BlackRock, JP Morgan, Fidelity top latest Broadridge Fund Brand 50 ranking

  • Equities
  • 16 March 2020
Lombard Odier unveils climate transition strategy

  • Thematic
  • 16 March 2020
Back to Top

Most read

HSBC appoints CEO for the Middle East region
HSBC appoints CEO for the Middle East region
People moves: Phoenix Group, Franklin Templeton, TMF Group, AJ Bell, Arete, Just Group
People moves: Phoenix Group, Franklin Templeton, TMF Group, AJ Bell, Arete, Just Group
Nordic Fund Selector of the Year 2021 shortlist announced
Nordic Fund Selector of the Year 2021 shortlist announced
UK Budget: Sunak freezes lifetime allowance for pensions contributions
UK Budget: Sunak freezes lifetime allowance for pensions contributions
Europe's wealth mangers increasingly focusing on Bitcoin: survey
Europe's wealth mangers increasingly focusing on Bitcoin: survey
  • Contact Us
  • Marketing solutions
  • About Incisive Media
  • Terms and conditions
  • Policies
  • Careers
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Newsletters

© Incisive Business Media (IP) Limited, Published by Incisive Business Media Limited, New London House, 172 Drury Lane, London WC2B 5QR, registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09177174 & 09178013

Digital publisher of the year
Digital publisher of the year 2010, 2013, 2016 & 2017
Loading