• Home
  • News
    • People moves
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • Caribbean
    • Domicile
    • Europe
    • Latin America
    • North America
    • Middle East
    • US
    • US
    • UK
  • Products
    • Funds
    • Pensions
    • Platforms
    • Insurance
    • Investments
    • Private Banking
    • Citizenship
    • Taxation
  • Fintech
  • Regulation
  • ESG
  • Expats
  • In Depth
  • Special Reports
  • Directory
  • Video
  • Advertise with us
  • Directory
  • Events
  • European Fund Selector
  • Newsletters
  • Follow us
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Newsletters
  • Advertise with us
  • Directory
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
      event logo
      International Investment Nordic Forum 2021

      International Investment is delighted to announce the 2021 International Investment Nordic Forum which will take place on Tuesday March 9, at 9am (GMT). This curated virtual event will be broadcast live and will feature a series of fund manager interviews and presentations, as well as interviews with some of the Nordic regions top fund selectors.

      • Date: 09 Mar 2021
      • ONLINE, ONLINE
      View all events
  • European Fund Selector
International Investment
International Investment

Sponsored by

Sharing Alpha
  • Home
  • News
  • Products
  • Fintech
  • Regulation
  • ESG
  • Expats
  • In Depth
  • Special Reports
  • Video
  • Thematic

It's time to make ESG data sustainable

It's time to make ESG data sustainable
  • Jeremy Richardson
  • 01 July 2019
  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  

Two people can look at the same thing and conclude differently. We may have the same inputs but attach more significance to certain aspects than others. Maybe we apply our own values or interpret the data through the lens of a unique personal experience. Reasonable people can disagree, but in ESG investing, it's also time that we set an agreed minimum standard. 

ESG factors have grown in importance to such an extent that today most investors are aware the moniker references environmental, social and governance factors. Yet the desire for simple ESG solutions has led to a divergence of some essential minimum standards. This lack of basic rules is now putting further progress at risk. 

Related articles

  • Investors must beware of pitfalls posed by ESG ratings
  • The side effects of ESG investing
  • Wharton School research using Truvalue Labs data spots link between ESG, credit events, credit risk
  • Dig for legitimacy: The case for good ESG in mining

A small number of influential ESG data providers have emerged to provide ESG ratings to paying customers as a simple solution. These new ratings are being used to create ESG indexes and capital is being allocated according to their opinions. Whilst this provides strong evidence of how ESG has become mainstream, it also raises questions about the sustainability of the ESG environment that has been created. 

Companies tell us that they find the volume of ESG questionnaires frustrating and confusing. They wrestle with complex real-world trade-offs but find these are not easily summarised into a tick-box approach. Nor do they find it obvious why diverse ESG issues, such as carbon or gender reporting, should be reported differently. 

From the user's perspective, many wonder why material ESG data isn't being treated the same way as material financial data. Principles of fair disclosure should mean that no investor is disadvantaged - everybody has access to the same data at the same time. But when it comes to ESG data, much of it is hidden behind a pay-wall to the disadvantage of smaller investors. 

The consolidation of ESG data providers has created a small number of highly influential firms that provokes justifiable comparison with the large index providers. Like them, their judgements can lead to the re-allocation of billions of dollars of capital and yet the ratings providers are typically subsidiaries of private companies with opaque governance structures and little public accountability. 

There is much then that isn't sustainable about the environment we have created for ESG and ESG data. The consolidation of ESG data in favour of ‘ESG by numbers' means we are losing valuable space to discuss subjective questions. Opinions are being outsourced to data tick-boxing with frequently dubious governance. The time has come for a proper discussion about what a more sustainable ESG environment could look like. 

Firstly, it is time for an ESG data charter to promote professional standards in the manipulation and presentation of ESG data. Compliance could be voluntary to begin with, but such a charter would address problems, like merging estimated and actual data in peer comparisons, and would boost confidence in the quality of the data upon which ratings opinions are ultimately based. 

Secondly, we need a common system for ESG disclosure like traditional financial reporting. This would lower the cost of obtaining and comparing material ESG data and ensure fair access for all. It would also lower barriers for new ESG data providers to enter the market and hopefully encourage others with better governance structures. 

Those of us who support ESG principles can be satisfied with the significant progress that has been made over the recent past. But it is somewhat ironic that a discipline so concerned with sustainability has arrived at a point where its own sustainability can be legitimately questioned. Others may have an alternative diagnosis and suggest different remedies, but the growing acceptance of ESG ideas means that it is an appropriate time for ESG practitioners to apply the same rigour to the agreed essentials of ESG as we do to our other professional activities. Hopefully on that, reasonable people can agree. 

Jeremy Richardson is senior portfolio manager with the Global Equity team at RBC GAM

  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
  • Topics
  • Thematic

More on Thematic

BlackRock launches ultrashort bond ESG ETFs range

  • Passive
  • 19 March 2020
Nikko AM releases 2019 sustainability report

  • Thematic
  • 18 March 2020
World Water Day beckons for ESG investors - KBIGI

  • Thematic
  • 17 March 2020
BlackRock, JP Morgan, Fidelity top latest Broadridge Fund Brand 50 ranking

  • Equities
  • 16 March 2020
Lombard Odier unveils climate transition strategy

  • Thematic
  • 16 March 2020
Back to Top

Most read

HSBC Singapore CEO to leave for Saudi British Bank
HSBC Singapore CEO to leave for Saudi British Bank
J.P. Morgan Asset Management launches Global Income Sustainable Fund
J.P. Morgan Asset Management launches Global Income Sustainable Fund
Comment: Four key issues powering the renewable energy revolution
Comment: Four key issues powering the renewable energy revolution
EU removes Barbados from blacklist of 'non-cooperative' jurisdictions
EU removes Barbados from blacklist of 'non-cooperative' jurisdictions
Expat exodus in Gulf states could continue into 2023: S&P report
Expat exodus in Gulf states could continue into 2023: S&P report
  • Contact Us
  • Marketing solutions
  • About Incisive Media
  • Terms and conditions
  • Policies
  • Careers
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Newsletters

© Incisive Business Media (IP) Limited, Published by Incisive Business Media Limited, New London House, 172 Drury Lane, London WC2B 5QR, registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09177174 & 09178013

Digital publisher of the year
Digital publisher of the year 2010, 2013, 2016 & 2017
Loading