• Home
  • News
    • People moves
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • Caribbean
    • Domicile
    • Europe
    • Latin America
    • North America
    • Middle East
    • US
    • US
    • UK
  • Products
    • Funds
    • Pensions
    • Platforms
    • Insurance
    • Investments
    • Private Banking
    • Citizenship
    • Taxation
  • Fintech
  • Regulation
  • ESG
  • Expats
  • In Depth
  • Special Reports
  • Directory
  • Video
  • Advertise with us
  • Directory
  • Events
  • European Fund Selector
  • Newsletters
  • Follow us
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Newsletters
  • Advertise with us
  • Directory
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
      event logo
      International Investment Nordic Forum 2021

      International Investment is delighted to announce the 2021 International Investment Nordic Forum which will take place on Tuesday March 9, at 9am (GMT). This curated virtual event will be broadcast live and will feature a series of fund manager interviews and presentations, as well as interviews with some of the Nordic regions top fund selectors.

      • Date: 09 Mar 2021
      • ONLINE, ONLINE
      View all events
  • European Fund Selector
International Investment
International Investment

Sponsored by

Sharing Alpha
  • Home
  • News
  • Products
  • Fintech
  • Regulation
  • ESG
  • Expats
  • In Depth
  • Special Reports
  • Video
  • Taxation

HMRC wins tax treaty case against S. African diver

HMRC wins tax treaty case against S. African diver
  • Christopher Copper-Ind
  • @intlinvestment
  • 01 June 2020
  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  

UK tax authority HMRC has won the right to tax the earnings of a South African resident who undertook diving work on the UK continental shelf.

The case involved Martin Fowler, a South African resident, and professional diver, who undertook diving engagements in the UK Continental Shelf waters.

Related articles

  • Explainer: South Africa's 'expat tax' - your questions answered
  • South Africa goes ahead with expat tax
  • DeVere CEO hits out at ‘unjust’ South African expat tax change
  • Some retired Brits in Cyprus could face higher taxes: Report

HMRC had claimed that the income he earned while on the diving assignments would be subject to UK tax.

The decision is useful in terms of clarifying how terms will be interpreted in a double tax treaty and confirms that when a fiction is created under one of the signatory's tax codes this will sometimes be disregarded so as not to lead to a result which appears contrary to the purpose of the treaty."

By contrast, Fowler insisted the income should be exempt from UK income tax, as Britain and South Africa have a double-taxation treaty (also known as a double-taxation agreement, or DTA)

The DTA between the two countries ensures employment income is taxed by the state where it is earned, yet self-employed and freelance workers are taxed where they are resident. Fowler's case appeared to bridge these two, as the income was earned in the UK, yet he was resident in South Africa.

Fowler claimed that for the purposes of interpreting the DTA, he should be viewed as self-employed. However, the London Supreme Court decided the South African authorities would be considered an employee by the tax authorities, and would therefore avoid paying any income tax altogether.

Lord Briggs, who delivered the judgment of the Supreme Court last week, said: "Nothing in the Treaty requires articles 7 [the business profits article] and 14 [the employment income article] to be applied to the fictional, deemed world which may be created by UK income tax legislation." 

"If one asks, as is required, for what purposes and between whom is the fiction [that employed divers are self employed] created, it is plainly not for the purpose of rendering a qualifying diver immune from tax in the UK, nor adjudicating between the UK and South Africa as the potential recipient of tax."

"It is for the purpose of adjusting the basis of a continuing UK income tax liability which arises from the receipt of employment income. Therefore to apply the deeming provision … so as to alter the meaning of terms in the Treaty with the result of rendering a qualifying diver immune from UK taxation would be contrary to its purpose. It would also produce an anomalous result."

Jake Landman, a tax disputes expert at law firm Pinsent Masons, said: "The decision is useful in terms of clarifying how terms will be interpreted in a double tax treaty and confirms that when a fiction is created under one of the signatory's tax codes this will sometimes be disregarded so as not to lead to a result which appears contrary to the purpose of the treaty."

Subscribe to International Investment's free, twice-daily, newsletter

  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
  • Topics
  • Taxation

More on Taxation

Report proposes 5% UK wealth tax to offset pandemic costs

  • Taxation
  • 09 December 2020
Britons in France warned of steep capital gains tax rises when selling property

  • Taxation
  • 07 December 2020
HMRC payments to tax evasion whistleblowers up 63%

  • Taxation
  • 04 December 2020
OECD to issue international crypto tax evasion standards next year

  • Cryptocurrencies
  • 04 December 2020
Global tax evasion costs $427bn per year

  • Taxation
  • 04 December 2020
Back to Top

Most read

SharingAlpha's 2020 top rated funds by category revealed
SharingAlpha's 2020 top rated funds by category revealed
Duff & Phelps opens Gibraltar office
Duff & Phelps opens Gibraltar office
Brexit deals hefty blow to City but industry is ready to fight back
Brexit deals hefty blow to City but industry is ready to fight back
Comment: Are cryptocurrencies the new gold?
Comment: Are cryptocurrencies the new gold?
Tabula launches world's first Paris-aligned fixed-income ETF
Tabula launches world's first Paris-aligned fixed-income ETF
  • Contact Us
  • Marketing solutions
  • About Incisive Media
  • Terms and conditions
  • Policies
  • Careers
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Newsletters

© Incisive Business Media (IP) Limited, Published by Incisive Business Media Limited, New London House, 172 Drury Lane, London WC2B 5QR, registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09177174 & 09178013

Digital publisher of the year
Digital publisher of the year 2010, 2013, 2016 & 2017
Loading