• Home
  • News
    • People moves
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • Caribbean
    • Domicile
    • Europe
    • Latin America
    • North America
    • Middle East
    • US
    • US
    • UK
  • Products
    • Funds
    • Pensions
    • Platforms
    • Insurance
    • Investments
    • Private Banking
    • Citizenship
    • Taxation
  • Fintech
  • Regulation
  • ESG
  • Expats
  • In Depth
  • Special Reports
  • Directory
  • Video
  • Advertise with us
  • Directory
  • Events
  • European Fund Selector
  • Newsletters
  • Follow us
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Newsletters
  • Advertise with us
  • Directory
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
      event logo
      International Investment Nordic Summit 2021

      International Investment Nordic Summit 

      • Date: 09 Mar 2021
      • ONLINE, ONLINE
      View all events
  • European Fund Selector
International Investment
International Investment

Sponsored by

Sharing Alpha
  • Home
  • News
  • Products
  • Fintech
  • Regulation
  • ESG
  • Expats
  • In Depth
  • Special Reports
  • Video
  • Pensions

Judge sides with SIPP provider Carey Pensions in landmark ruling

Judge sides with SIPP provider Carey Pensions in landmark ruling
  • Hannah Godfrey & Christopher Copper-Ind
  • 18 May 2020
  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  

Carey Pensions has won its long-running legal battle against former client Russell Adams, with Adams's claims dismissed on all grounds after a two-year court battle.

STM Group announced the outcome of the judgement in the long-awaited pensions case this morning.

Related articles

  • STM eyes UK auto-enrolment market with Carey purchase
  • STM Group completes acquisition of UK pensions business
  • Police end investigation into head of international pensions firm STM
  • STM Group profits flat as company looks to new QROPS acquisitions

The judgment was handed down on Monday morning (18 May) and related to a claim by Adams against Carey Pensions for loss of value on an investment that was held within a self-invested personal pension (SIPP).

The judgement is a very welcome and clear precedent for the whole of the UK financial services sector given the increased litigation and use of the Financial Ombudsman to determine complaints. This judgment gives a solid legal footing for these to now be considered in the context of this ruling."

The case was heard in March 2018 and the result has been keenly awaited becuase it will now give clarity on the duty and obligations of SIPP providers.

Carey Pensions was merged with STM Group in 2018.

Lorry driver Russell Adams had alleged Carey Pensions mis-sold him a SIPP. He and his lawyers accused the SIPP firm of using a Spain-based unregulated introducer to facilitate investments in Store First unit pods.

In July 2012, Adams invested £50,000 into Store First unit pods. Over the years, the funds have depleted and are now virtually worthless.

During the 2018 trial, Adams' legal representatives argued the pension administrator breached Financial Conduct Authority COBS rules that dictate a firm must act in a client's best interest. They claimed that, if the firm had been doing so, it would have declined to give business to this sort of "high-risk and highly speculative investment".

They also argued that, if Adams had received "competent financial advice", it was unlikely he would have been put into a SIPP in the first place.

Carey's defence team argued the pension administrator was "blameless" for the loss, however, but the client was not.

The court heard Carey Pensions had warned Adams the investment was high-risk and highly speculative, but Adams chose to go ahead anyway to claim a £4,000 inducement from the introducer, which Carey Pensions chief executive Christine Hallett said the firm reported to HM Revenue & Customs.

Carey's lawyers added that SIPP providers were under no obligation to ascertain to what extent an investment is high-risk and reject that investment.  

This morning's judgment relates to a claim by Adams against Carey Pensions UK for loss of value in an investment which was held within a SIPP wrapper. The case opened in March 2018.

Alan Kentish, Chief Executive of STM Group, commented: "The judgment is a very welcome and clear precedent for the whole of the UK financial services sector given the increased litigation and use of the Financial Ombudsman to determine complaints. This judgment gives a solid legal footing for these to now be considered in the context of this ruling."

"The STM Board considers that potential implications for any financial institution carrying out execution-only business to have become wholly responsible for their client's decisions would be inequitable and inappropriate. I am sure many financial service providers and institutions, as well as their respective trade associations, would wholeheartedly agree and can now look to the future with greater confidence post this ruling."

Christine Hallett, managing director of Carey (now rebranded as ‘Options, for your tomorrow'), said: "We are pleased that the judgment has now been delivered, and that the judge has found in our favour on all counts."

"It has been a long time coming and while we were confident of our position, the lengthy, comprehensive and detailed judgment recognises within it our approach to implementing strong contractual agreements and documentation, together with robust systems, controls and processes within the business. It was also clear that as a SIPP provider we are expected to carry out executiononly business based on decisions made by our clients."

She add: "It is a judgment that has been long awaited by the SIPP industry and consumers alike, and gives clarity to what is expected of a SIPP provider under English law and the FCA Conduct of Business Principles when acting upon the instructions of a client. In addition, it has given a much better understanding of the legal relationship between an introducer and the service provider which will provide valuable guidance for both consumers and industry professionals."

"We now look forward to turning our minds to growing our UK businesses and maintaining our service levels for our clients."

 

Subscribe to International Investment's free, twice-daily, newsletter

  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
  • Topics
  • Pensions
  • Legal
  • Carey Pensions
  • Russell Adams
  • STM group
  • SIPP
  • Spain-based
  • HM Revenue & Customs
  • Christine Hallett
  • Carey Pensions UK
  • English
  • UK
  • STM Board
  • FCA

More on Pensions

FCA data reveals £20bn of DB pensions advised to transfer in 2018-20

  • Pensions
  • 18 January 2021
Digital switch must accelerate to meet demand: iPensions Group

  • Fintech
  • 15 January 2021
Pensions and investments could be tapped for £800m in UK's dormant assets

  • Pensions
  • 11 January 2021
Pence 'unlikely' to pursue 25th amendment as Trump concedes election

  • Legal
  • 08 January 2021
FCA identifies 30,000 instances of unregulated activity in 2020

  • Pensions
  • 06 January 2021
Back to Top

Most read

SharingAlpha's 2020 top rated funds by category revealed
SharingAlpha's 2020 top rated funds by category revealed
Duff & Phelps opens Gibraltar office
Duff & Phelps opens Gibraltar office
DeVere launches equity fund with Columbia Threadneedle Investments
DeVere launches equity fund with Columbia Threadneedle Investments
HNWIs in SE Asia cite lack of financial knowledge as greatest concern: report
HNWIs in SE Asia cite lack of financial knowledge as greatest concern: report
DeVere Group to offer free ESG advice to clients
DeVere Group to offer free ESG advice to clients
  • Contact Us
  • Marketing solutions
  • About Incisive Media
  • Terms and conditions
  • Policies
  • Careers
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Newsletters

© Incisive Business Media (IP) Limited, Published by Incisive Business Media Limited, New London House, 172 Drury Lane, London WC2B 5QR, registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09177174 & 09178013

Digital publisher of the year
Digital publisher of the year 2010, 2013, 2016 & 2017
Loading