• Home
  • News
    • People moves
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • Caribbean
    • Domicile
    • Europe
    • Latin America
    • North America
    • Middle East
    • US
    • US
    • UK
  • Products
    • Funds
    • Pensions
    • Platforms
    • Insurance
    • Investments
    • Private Banking
    • Citizenship
    • Taxation
  • Fintech
  • Regulation
  • ESG
  • Expats
  • In Depth
  • Special Reports
  • Directory
  • Video
  • Advertise with us
  • Directory
  • Events
  • European Fund Selector
  • Newsletters
  • Follow us
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Newsletters
  • Advertise with us
  • Directory
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
      event logo
      International Investment Nordic Forum 2021

      International Investment is delighted to announce the 2021 International Investment Nordic Forum which will take place on Tuesday March 9, at 9am (GMT). This curated virtual event will be broadcast live and will feature a series of fund manager interviews and presentations, as well as interviews with some of the Nordic regions top fund selectors.

      • Date: 09 Mar 2021
      • ONLINE, ONLINE
      View all events
  • European Fund Selector
International Investment
International Investment

Sponsored by

Sharing Alpha
  • Home
  • News
  • Products
  • Fintech
  • Regulation
  • ESG
  • Expats
  • In Depth
  • Special Reports
  • Video
  • Funds

ETF investors face highest risk as oil volatility batters energy funds

Schroder ISF Global Energy and TB Guinness Global Energy are the worst-hit energy funds year to date
Schroder ISF Global Energy and TB Guinness Global Energy are the worst-hit energy funds year to date
  • Mike Sheen
  • Mike Sheen
  • 27 April 2020
  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  

Extreme volatility seen in oil price movements over the past week, as the coronavirus pandemic continues to severely hamper demand for the commodity, could lead to emergency measures for hard hit energy funds, yet mass flows into oil ETFs may leave passive investors exposed to much greater risks.

WTI Crude futures dipped as far as $30 into negative territory for the first time in history early last week, largely due to reduced demand for the May contract and limited purchaser storing space, which was then followed by heavy falls in Brent Crude futures.

Related articles

  • Changing oil prices prompt search for energy exposure
  • Oil price, energy security a new worry for investors
  • Rising oil price prompts search for energy exposure
  • The imminent end of crude's dead cat bounce

Prices recovered slightly later in the week, at least in part owing to renewed tensions between the White House and Iran, with Brent and WTI Crude futures trading at $21.80 and $15 per barrel (bl) respectively at time of publication.

The volatility has led to heavy losses across energy funds, which had already struggled amid historically low prices, with WTI Crude futures continuing to fall since they started the year trading at around $63.

Schroder ISF Global Energy and TB Guinness Global Energy are the worst-hit year to date, down 54.6% and 45.2% respectively according to FE fundinfo.

Of the 11 funds identified in the IA universe as explicitly "energy" funds, just four have total AUMs of more than £100m as at 22 April.

Notably, the trend of ‘sustainable' investments outperforming ‘mainstream' counterparts, which has proliferated so far in this crisis, is borne out in the energy fund performance figures, as shown in the table above.

Head of personal investing at investment platform Willis Owen Adrian Lowcock warned soon after the price falls and if price weakness persists "we may see some emergency steps introduced to prevent a rout" on energy funds "purely exposed to the sector."

ETF investors flood into oil
Despite heavy losses for energy funds, investors have piled into oil ETFs in recent weeks. Retail investors alone poured almost £2bn into European ETFs explicitly investing in oil between 1 January and 22 April 2020, according to Morningstar estimates.

Portfolio manager at Franklin Equity Group Matt Adams explained that as large flows into oil ETFs have "supported prices in recent weeks", the WTI price in particular is "disconnected from physical oil prices on the ground".

Senior analyst, manager research specialising in passive strategies at Morningstar UK, Kenneth Lamont noted that with the oil price hitting $100bl as recently as August 2014, the price dislocation is "striking", which has not gone unnoticed by ETF investors.

However, he warned: "Investors in oil ETCs should beware. Buying cheap oil using an ETC may seem tempting, but the complexities and idiosyncrasies of the crude futures markets mean that you can lose money even if oil prices rise. For most investors, this approach is best left to specialists".

Despite the current popularity of exchange traded products investing in oil at present, WisdomTree was forced to close one of its products on Wednesday (22 April), owing to "extreme adverse moves in oil futures".

It followed the world's largest oil-backed ETF, the $4bn United States Oil fund, being forced to overhaul its portfolio as sub-zero oil prices raised the possibility of unlimited losses for investors.

Portfolio manager of the Vontobel Commodity fund, which is down by 14.6% over past month, Mike Salden was among those warning that high ETF inflows amid current extreme volatility could leave investors with heavy losses.

He explained the current "super-contango", where the futures price of oil is far higher than the spot price, means that "investment in ETFs currently harbours high risks to investors who might be tempted to passively invest in oil due to ultra-low prices".

Salden added: "Losses occur when big index trackers must roll their spot exposure upon contract expiry since they are exposed to negative roll returns. Conversely, funds offering exposure to longer-dated oil offer lower volatility and more attractive roll returns."

CIO at Rathbones Julian Chillingworth noted ETFs are "not in a position to ever take physical delivery regardless of whether the capacity is full or not", and this is "exacerbated by the fact that capacity was full, so other professional oil traders could not find anywhere to put physical oil".

He warned ETF oil positions "will unwind quite dramatically" as "a lot of people will be quite badly burned in those ETF positions".

Active funds retreat to safety
While oil ETFs "are not in such a good place", active funds with more exposure to the oil majors as opposed to smaller producers should be better placed to ride out volatility for the asset class, according to managing director of FundCalibre Darius McDermott.

McDermott identified Guinness Global Energy as one fund that should weather the storm well owing to its bias towards quality names.

"BP and Shell will not go bust," he explained: "We will still need energy infrastructure. For them it is about picking the more resilient companies that can get through this - the more resilient ones."

Co-manager of Guinness Global Energy Jonathan Waghorn told Investment Week the fund, while typically a low-turnover vehicle, sold seven of its most financially-exposed portfolio companies at the beginning of March and has reduced its beta exposure to "about as low as we have ever had."

He added the fund will remain "defensively positioned" until the management team can have greater confidence that oil demand will rebound, at which point the team "has room to tilt the portfolio back to a more aggressive stance."

Similarly, portfolio manager of Ninety One's Global Energy fund, formerly the Investec Global Energy fund, Tom Nelson explained the management team have focussed on quality names, which are "best placed to generate free cashflow and return" and "most able to weather this challenging period for the energy sector."

This article was first published by Investment Week

  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
  • Topics
  • Funds
  • Commodities
  • oil futures
  • WTI Crude
  • Schroder ISF Global Energy
  • Morningstar
  • United States
  • ETF
  • Oil
  • crude oil
  • Commodities
  • Energy
  • Energy stocks
  • Geopolitical risk
  • geopolitical risks
  • US
  • North America
  • Iran
  • Coronavirus
  • Covid-19

More on Funds

AJ Bell's eight fund and trust picks for 2021

  • Funds
  • 07 December 2020
Union Bancaire Privée launches global fintech equity fund

  • Funds
  • 05 November 2020
The SPDR Bloomberg SASB Euro Corporate ESG UCITS ETF is available from today
SSGA launches US and European ESG bond ETFs

Bloomberg SASB indices

  • ESG
  • 21 October 2020
VIDEO: Genesis MD Antoine Bastain on fund evolution in The Bahamas

  • Funds
  • 07 October 2020
Markets destabilised by Trump catching covid-19 and oil price fall

  • Commodities
  • 02 October 2020
Back to Top

Most read

Duff & Phelps opens Gibraltar office
Duff & Phelps opens Gibraltar office
Brexit deals hefty blow to City but industry is ready to fight back
Brexit deals hefty blow to City but industry is ready to fight back
Comment: Are cryptocurrencies the new gold?
Comment: Are cryptocurrencies the new gold?
FSCS warns industry of £1bn compensation bill
FSCS warns industry of £1bn compensation bill
Dubai regulator to develop cryptocurrency framework
Dubai regulator to develop cryptocurrency framework
  • Contact Us
  • Marketing solutions
  • About Incisive Media
  • Terms and conditions
  • Policies
  • Careers
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Newsletters

© Incisive Business Media (IP) Limited, Published by Incisive Business Media Limited, New London House, 172 Drury Lane, London WC2B 5QR, registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09177174 & 09178013

Digital publisher of the year
Digital publisher of the year 2010, 2013, 2016 & 2017
Loading